Vilifying Israel By Counter-Example
From AP:
The caption states:
Palestinian construction workers build a new housing development in an east Jerusalem neighborhood, Wednesday, Dec. 5, 2007.
In a move that could hamper the U.S. peace push, Israel on Tuesday announced plans to build more than 300 new homes in a disputed east Jerusalem neighborhood. Palestinians warned that the move will undermine the newly revived peace talks. The new housing would expand Har Homa, a Jewish neighborhood of about 4,000 residents in an area Palestinians claim as capital of a future state. Palestinian officials appealed to the U.S. to block the project.
So the only way that AP could illustrate the horror of Jews wanting to live in their holy city is by showing that they allow Arabs to build large housing complexes – in the Jewish holy city.
Similarly, from Reuters:
Malek, a two-and-a-half year old Palestinian girl from the West Bank village of Bidiya, undergoes heart surgery at an Israeli hospital in Holon, near Tel Aviv, October 21, 2007. Palestinians suffering serious illnesses have long traveled from Gaza to nearby Israeli hospitals for treatments unavailable at facilities in the territory, which is home to 1.5 million people and was occupied by Israel for 38 years until 2005. However Israel has tightened border restrictions since Hamas Islamists seized control of the coastal enclave in June.
This time the wire service cannot say with certainly that Israel doesn’t allow people from Gaza to be treated in Israel – but it can imply it, playing the Hamas playbook.
The wire services try so hard to illustrate Israeli cruelty to the point that they will caption Israeli benevolence – that one would never see on the Arab side – as if it is cruelty.
(cross-posted on Elder of Ziyon )
CORRECTION: Commenters here indicate that the top picture really is an Israeli building project in Har Homa, so my first example is wrong.
Filed Under: Uncategorized
About the Author: Elder of Ziyon may or may not be a real person. He (or she, or it) blogs at 
reminds me of the stuff talked about in the book “the Other War” by Stephanie Gutman, also about anti-israel media bias. Ridiculous shit, that.
Example 2 is valid, example 1 is valid. The Palestinians are the construction workers, not the residents to be. (I’m fairly certain I’ve seen the illustration of the completed project postered to the wall in the picture in various local Jewish papers, advertising apartments for sale in Har Homa.) And the AP caption says nothing about who is to live in the construction project. You’ve twisted the meaning inside out in a masterful way rarely seen outside of the PLO.
Far be it from me to be a big Arab supporter, but kishnevi is correct – the first picture is of Arabs building in Har Homa – not exactly showing how rosy life is for Arabs in the Holy City.