IDF Concludes Investigation Into Gaza Beach Incident

The IDF has concluded its investigation of one of the most tragic incidents from last summer’s war, in which four young boys, Ahed Atef Bakr, Zakariya Ahed Bakr, Mohammad Ramiz Bakr, and Ismail Mahmoud Bakr, lost their lives on the beach in Gaza on July 16, 2014. This is from IDF Spokesperson Lt. Col. Peter Lerner’s facebook page:

From the factual findings collected by the investigators, it revealed that the incident took place in an area that had long been known as a compound belonging to Hamas’s Naval Police and Naval Force (including naval commandos), and which was utilized exclusively by militants. The compound in question spans the length of the breakwater of the Gaza City seashore, closed off by a fence and clearly separated from the beach serving the civilian population. It further found in the course of the investigation (including from the affidavits provided by Palestinian witnesses), that the compound was known to the residents of the Gaza Strip as a compound which was used exclusively by Hamas’s Naval Police.

The IDF carried out a number of attacks on the compound in the days prior to the incident. In the course of one such attack, which took place on the day prior to the incident (15 July 2014), a container located inside the compound, which was used to store military supplies, was attacked.

Shortly before the incident, an intelligence assessment was established which indicated that operatives from Hamas’s Naval Forces would gather in the military compound in order to prepare for military activity against the IDF. On 16 July, aerial surveillance identified a number of figures entering the compound at a running pace. These figures entered a shed adjoining the container which had been attacked the day prior. Against the backdrop of the aforementioned intelligence assessment, these were believed to be militants from Hamas’s Naval Forces, who had arrived at the compound in order to prepare to execute the aforementioned military activity against the IDF. It should be stressed that the figures were not identified at any point during the incident, as children.

In light of the above, it was decided to conduct an aerial attack against the figures which had been identified, after all the necessary authorizations for an attack had been obtained, and after a civilian presence in the area had been ruled out. When one of the identified figures entered into the remains of the container which had been attacked on the day prior to the incident, one missile was fired from the air towards the container and the adjoining shed. As a result of this attack, it appeared that one of the figures identified was hit. Following this attack, the rest of the figures began to run in the direction of the compound’s exit. Shortly before their exit from the compound, an additional missile was fired from the air towards them, which hit the figures in question after they had exited the compound.
Tragically, in the wake of the incident it became clear that the outcome of the attack was the death of four children, who had entered the military compound for reasons that remain unclear. It further arose from the investigation that, under the circumstances in question, it would not have been possible for the operational entities involved to have identified these figures, via aerial surveillance, as children.

After reviewing the investigation’s findings, the Military Advocate General found that the attack process in question accorded with Israeli domestic law and international law requirements.

I think we can all find it in our hearts to appreciate the unspeakable sadness of this incident, and angry at the circumstances that led to it. At the same time, we can acknowledge and appreciate that the IDF has gone to great lengths to avoid situations such as this, but in the end intelligence during wartime is by definition imperfect, and it is inevitable that unintended consequences will sometimes occur.

4 thoughts on “IDF Concludes Investigation Into Gaza Beach Incident”

  1. The IDF has posted many clips on its YouTube channel in which it aborted strikes after spotting civilians in the targeted area. It seems to me that they would spot the civilians from aerial footage. Why is it that in this incident they were unable to identify that they were civilians?

    1. Intelligence on enemies during war is imperfect. No matter how many times they get it right, there will always be times that, for whatever reason, it’s impossible to do so.

    2. I think the technology to identify civilian vs. military from aerial surveillance just really doesn’t exist. Especially when you consider that many Hamas militants don’t wear uniforms. The army has to make an educated guess based on behavior, and whether the individuals appear to be carrying weapons. One eyewitness account from a surviving child in the group (NPR) suggests that they were playing “Jew and Arab” and carrying sticks to look like guns. Combine that with the fact that they were running into a structure known to be an IDF target due to Hamas activity (corroborated by foreign journalists reporting on the event)…it was a tragic mistake.

      Also, if you look back to the original reports there was an injured 21-year-old male with them. He has been either conveniently forgotten, or described as a “boy”.

      http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/1.605568

    3. nobody is perfect

      warfare is far from perfect

      hamas uses civilians, especially children as human shields

      blame them

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top