More results...

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

More results...

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

To Whom It May Concern: It’s Cropped!

I was so excited. The itinerary said we were going to Joseph’s Tomb. But the reality was not quite the same as seen on paper.

Shechm Joseph's Tomb
Joseph’s Tomb

We did go to see Joseph’s tomb, but I needed a good zoom lens and crop to get this photo.

spot where tourist can see Nabulus

For Jewish tourists to see Joseph’s Tomb, unless they go in the middle of the night with an army escort, there is Joseph’s Lookout point, high above ancient Shechem, or the place now called Nablus.

The Guardian has published To Whom it May Concern review – searing images of Israel by Haaretz. This fine arts exhibition of “searing images” is in a gallery in New York.

crowded housing in refugee camp in Nablus

One featured “searing image” is of a horribly over crowded refugee camp, similar to this one.

HOWEVER,

image of Nablus refugee camp

check out the uncropped photo, not so searing with touch of green field in background.

BUT, do not stop there,

Nablus refugee camp

here is a fuller view of the same scene. Perhaps, still “visually confusing,” but not nearly as “morally unfathomable” as the small clustered dwellings of refugee camps we are shown.

NOW, for the full scene, please note the minaret in the photo.

view of Nablus, Scechem for Joseph's lookout

The minaret is circled in white to help you find it.

The sprawling growth of new Nablus is not nearly as dramatic as a photo of the crowded old refugee camps.

Nablus view from outlook

What is morally unfathomable is that the Arab world has kept the charade of these camps going for decades.  To keep their poor oppressed people narrative going, these crowded UN supervised, tax free neighborhoods are considered desirable.

Certainly photos cropped just right make for searing images. Images that put Israel in a negative light. While fine art draws on emotions, these images do not show the whole picture or tell a true story. Nablus is sprawling with new buildings and neighborhoods, but that is not the story Hareetz or the Guardian wants you to see.

When was the last time you saw a photo of Nablus that was not cropped?

4 thoughts on “To Whom It May Concern: It’s Cropped!”

    1. Look how Nablus has grown and spread out in those years, with beautiful new buildings (legal ones?). How many have ever seen that reality?

      1. But wait, I thought Israel only granted one West Bank Palestinian building permit in all of 2014, how can that be….???

        1. Someone responded to me earlier, then deleted it. Just to clarify, that “one building permit” statistic applies to Area C. Most of Hebron is in Areas A and B, as are the majority of Palestinian population centers. For most Palestinians, new construction in their communities does not require any permits from Israel.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top