Know Your History: The ‘Palestinian Refugees’ (NY Times May 19, 1957)

series where I bring to you news from the archives and historical documents to debunk common misconceptions about the Middle East conflict.

On May 19, 1957, James A Pike, a self-confessed non-Zionist, wrote a piece in the New York Times describing the palestinian refugee issue and possible solutions. It is a revealing and important read, given it acknowledges the situation is not as the haters claim (that Israel expelled the palestinian Arabs).

Note in particular:

  • The quoted number of refugees – way less than UNRWA’s number of 5 million that is based on a definition including descendants
  • The reasons for the Arabs fleeing Israel – including threats by their fellow Arabs, and hopes they could return after Israel was vanquished
  • Those who were scared of Israel based it on the actions of Jewish fighters not acting in an official capacity, who acted partly due to fear of a fifth column
  • The Arabs who stayed in Israel fared well
  • Arab opposition to resettlement of the refugees and the use of the refugees as political pawns
  • An acknowledgement that Israel could not take in the refugees, given our size and the fact they would be a fifth column
  • The instability refugees caused Jordan
  • Israel’s efforts in resettling 400,00 Jews from Arab lands

Note: I cannot provide a link to the full article since it is only available to those who have purchased a NY Times subscription. But I have provided screenshots below.

Click on the images to enlarge.

Tags:

David Lange

A law school graduate, David Lange transitioned from work in the oil and hi-tech industries into fulltime Israel advocacy. He is a respected commentator and Middle East analyst who has often been cited by the mainstream media