But to be thrown under the bus by our fellow Jews who claim to be pro-Israel? Highly disappointing and infuriating.
The Stanford Israel Association (SIA)—a student group at the California-based university that claims it “aims to engage Stanford students with all that the Jewish State has to offer, through culture, politics, and identity”—pulled its support for a program highlighting the stories of Israel’s minority populations.
In a statement released on Facebook late Sunday to announce its decision, SIA cited “a combination of procedural issues and concerns raised by the University regarding past behavior by the organization due to speak,” Reservists on Duty (RoD).
The event, “Stories From Israeli Minorities,” was scheduled to take place less than 24 hours later at the campus’s Hillel facility. Instead, Stanford Chabad stepped in to host RoD Monday night, and the event went on as planned.
“Our ultimate goal as the premier pro-Israel group at Stanford is to advocate for a more positive campus conversation regarding the Jewish state,” SIA told the Haym Salomon Center regarding its decision. “Given the concerns raised to us from the Stanford administration regarding RoD’s past behavior on other campuses, we do not believe this event would have furthered that goal. We regret not being able to promote the voices of Israel’s minorities, as was the purpose of the event, though we are certainly looking into opportunities to do so in the near future.”
While the reference to RoD’s “past behavior on other campuses” remains unclear, the most recent noteworthy event took place in May 2017 at University of California, Irvine.
Hosted by Students Supporting Israel, IDF reservists speaking on behalf of RoD had to be escorted out by police following a violent protest by anti-Israel students. The Jewish, Christian and Muslim IDF delegation was on campus to counter “Israeli Apartheid Week” events at the university.
The protest was documented on video by smartphone cameras, ultimately leading to the anti-Zionist group Students for Justice in Palestine being placed on disciplinary probation for two academic years.
“As a Jew, I don’t know what to say to the delegation [that was scheduled to speak at Stanford],” said Amit Deri, founder of RoD. “They are a group of minorities, one Druze, one Bedouin, one Muslim and one Arab, who suffered a lot of criticism from the Arab community in Israel. They’ve flown all the way from Israel to San Francisco for an event that was confirmed a month ago. And now, a few hours before it was to begin, they cancel it. I don’t know what to say to my people. I felt ashamed.”
He added, “As far as ‘past behavior’ is concerned, our ‘past behavior’ at UC Irvine resulted in the sanctioning of SJP because they shut down our event. When I saw the SIA statement, I didn’t know what to think. This Arab delegation came all the way from Israel, left their jobs. They’re not getting paid, they are all volunteers. They left their life behind, suffered a lot of criticism from their society because they chose to defend Israel abroad—and hours before the event, they say they are canceling. I think it’s a shame. We felt very offended.”
Stanford Hillel said in a statement that it chose to cancel the RoD event “due to concerns raised by the University.” The university did not immediately respond to a request for comment seeking clarification about its “concerns.”
A look at their Facebook page shows that SIA are indeed pro-Israel. But they seem very preoccupied with “peace”, with many photos like this
And peace is all well and good, but not at any cost.
And it seems that SIA have chosen “peace” on campus at the expense of their dignity.
Update: From 2015:
“It was very unfortunate to see anti-Semitism on Stanford’s campus,” said Kadisha, explaining that events like these are part of what she sees as a pattern.
“I don’t want to speculate to the cause of the vandalism, but after divestment, there has been a rise in hostility towards Jewish communities,” she added.
She also explained that many student groups have started refusing to co-sponsor events with the Stanford Israel Association.
Looks to me like SIA really want the other kids to play nice with them – hence this capitulation.
Please help ensure Israellycool can keep going, by donating one time or monthly