Beinart vs Gordis Deathmatch


On Wednesday, Peter Beinart and Daniel Gordis debated the proposition: “Zionism is a failing experiment—and American Jews are hastening its decline.”

Watch live streaming video from tabletmagazine at

Here’s a review of the debate. I personally thought Gordis won it, although more on points than by knockout punch. But I acknowledge the fact that my opinion on the debate result is largely colored by my own knowledge of the conflict and beliefs. I simply think Beinart got many things wrong.

Meanwhile, here is one of Gordis’ tweets after the debate, which indicates that perhaps he doesn’t have such warm feelings towards Beinart after all.

I am going to recommend you buy Gordis’ book, which I have read. I don’t agree with everything in it, but it is a worthwhile, thought-provoking read. You can order it via the below widget, which offers the advantage of helping support Israellycool!

As for Beinart’s book, I wouldn’t bother.

Please help ensure Israellycool can keep going,
by donating one time or monthly

A lawyer by education, David Lange - founder and managing editor of Israellycool - found his calling in advocating for Israel and the Jewish people. He is available for public speaking engagements.