US Army vs IDF

Nearly two years ago, I posted about the US Navy Seals battling IDF Commandos on Deadliest Warrior. On that episode, the Navy Seals defeated the Israelis.

Now Time has an article about a Jewish American who served in the IDF and is now serving in the US army, placing him in a position to compare the two armies.

Excerpt:

Army photo by Capt. Kyle Key

Daniel Houten is in basic training to become an infantryman in the U.S. Army at Fort Benning, Ga. Nothing unusual about another 11 Bravo – except that he recently finished an 18-month tour with the Israeli Defence Forces. The heck with generals and colonels weighing each army’s pluses and minuses – let’s talk to someone who really knows the differences between two of the world’s finest fighting forces.

He may be singing to the choir here, but Private Houten, 20, says the U.S. Army has better food, boots and uniforms than the Israel army he left in June. “The food is better here,” he says. “Americans in general have better equipment, newer equipment.” And he says the Israeli army is a more relaxed, less disciplined outfit than his new employer.

Read the whole thing.

Thoughts?

About Aussie Dave

An Aussie immigrant to Israel, Aussie Dave is founder and managing editor of Israellycool, one of the world's most popular pro-Israel blogs (and the one you are currently reading) He is a happy family man, and a lover of steak, Australian sports and girlie drinks

Facebook Comments

  • Jim from Iowa

    Oh, c’mon, Dave. Could there have been any other outcome? America is the one and only world super power. Israel is a regional power at best. Better disciplined? Check. Better equipment? Check. Better food? Wait a minute. The food in the IDF has got to be awful to be worse than American military food.

  • http://www.lastexiled.com K’Shoshana

    Sure the US has all the neat toys and clothes, bells and whistles etc., but its veterans suffer from outrageouly high rates of post-traumatic stress disorder – unlike the IDF.

  • StamEhad

    What? No more loof?

  • Naftali

    Notice that he focuses on the comforts, not the combat. Of course, he was a Machunai in Tzahal. No disrespect, but that’s not representative.

  • Justin

    Thanks for sharing. One thing I don’t get about Israeli soldiers is the sagging pants.

  • daniel

    I was misquoted just fyi, i said discipline is different in Israel, not inferior

Israellycool is testing Sovevos. Click for more info.