Thank You Arab MK Hecklers

stephen_harper

 

Edit: Here’s the video.

About Deebo

I'm a Canadian Israeli, Aliyah Class of '10. You may know me as tweeter AntiIsrael Douchebag (@notantisemitic) but here I'll tickle your Zionist bone in other ways.

comments

  • tom

    To call them stupid in this situation would be the best compliment.
    I mean, how dumb can a person be: They are sitting in the Israeli government and trying to destroy the country from inside. They can express whatever they want and even enjoy, one of many many benefits as a MK, legal protection (don’t know what the right word would be in English).

    You have to be quite infantile to eat your own vomit and lies :-)

  • cba

    The CBC have given Tibi a platform on their website to give his side http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ahmad-tibi-why-i-walked-out-on-stephen-harper-s-speech-1.2503975

    I didn’t play the video, but I did find the photograph over Tibi’s right shoulder (to the left of the screen) very interesting.

    • mrzee

      Leave it to the CBC to provide a platform for someone trying to insult and embarrass our PM.

      • http://wwrtc.blogspot.com Art Deco

        The media are s%&$bags everywhere. Denis Thatcher on the BBC: “[Margaret] was stitched up by a bunch of poofs and trots”.

  • http://wwrtc.blogspot.com Art Deco

    The trouble is that Israel has managed to build a prosperous economy while absorbing masses of immigrants. The only other societies in the Near East and adjacent regions which have managed to build prosperous economies (with or without masses of immigrants) not dependent on natural resource bonanzas are Cyprus, Bahrain, Dubai, and (if you stretch the definition), Lebanon and Turkey. The only other societies where civil peace and something resembling constitutional government have been the mode (though not a constant presence) since 1948 are Morocco, Kuwait, Cyprus, and Turkey. Israel’s prosperous and pluralistic societies are benefits that Arab societies have seldom been able to build and maintain for themselves. You either have to swallow your embarrassment or manufacture a grievance. Something Thomas Sowell said: constructive responses to challenges are not the mode in human history; recrimination is the mode.

  • JRmo

    if only Harper would have used the word “chutzpah” somewhere in his speech

  • IronyDome

    LOL Tibi’s a moron. You’re sitting IN THE FREAKING ISRAELI KNESSET and you have the gall to complain that Israel is an apratheid state that discriminates against Arabs??

  • Gustavo CL

    It surprises me that one has to explain that but when one says that Israel is an apartheid state he is not referring to Israel in its 1967 borders. No one, even the most flamant anti-Israeli, puts that in doubt. They refer to ACTUAL Israeli territory, that is, the territory that Israel de facto controls. In this territory live about 13 million people and only some 8 million have the right of citizenship. And the criteria to have this right is largely based on ethnicity. A jew in the West Bank (or Judea and Samaria if you like) has the right of citizenship, a christian or muslim arab not. This is apartheid, plain and simple.

    • http://wwrtc.blogspot.com Art Deco

      No, it is not plain and simple. If the population on the West Bank wishes to have their own state, they can bargain for it. They do not. They wish to dissolve the Jewish state.

      • Kane

        A people shouldn’t have to “bargain”, to express their basic civil/political rights. A majority of Palestinians (via polls) want a two-state solution, but as illegal settlements in the West Bank continue, they may began opting for a democratic one-state solution, which would spell trouble for the resulting minority Jewish population.

        I personally don’t describe Israel as an “apartheid state”, but if one wishes to defend Israel against the label, they must realize that Israel is accountable not just for the Arab minority within the green-line (who are treated well), but the Arabs within the West Bank and Gaza (who are treated like crap).

        • Allahisgrat

          SETTLEMENTS ARE NOT ILLEGAL. go ask OBAMA

          Not one binding authoritative law on the planet says they’re illegal. In fault Israel has more right to ALL OF JUDAH AND SAMARIA THAN ANY PALESTINIAN ARAB

          These mostly Muslim Arabs are mainly immigrants who came AFTER the Zionists in the late 19th century. The Arabs are colonialists who stole the land from the Jews.

          These imperialist Arabs marauded throughout the Middle East killing raping and slaving on the way.

          THE JEWS ARE RIGHTFULLY RECLAIMING THEIR HOMELAND. ITS CALLED ZIONISM

          They’ve lived there for over THREE THOUSAND YRS. Thousand if yrs before any Muslim Arab eh?

          Ps check your facts THE VAST MAJORITY OF PALS WANT ONE SATE NO JEWS NO ISRAE!!!!!!

          Any Arabs treated like crap are done so by OTHER MAINLY MUSLIM ARABS. those in Israel are treated just fine

          How are Jews in Palestine treated Kane?…….

          • Kane

            1.) The UN, International Court, Human Rights Organizations, and the legally binding Security Council, have ALL said settlements in Gaza, the West Bank, and Jerusalem, are illegal.

            2.) Who cares when they came, as long as they owned the land? A lot of Muslim Arabs immigrated to Palestine after 1900. The vast majority of Jews in Palestine didn’t arrive until 1915. That doesn’t take away basic rights for either group.

            3.) The Palestinians as we know them didn’t rampage, enslave, or kill anybody. If you are talking about history hundreds of years ago, be aware that Jews in both the Islamic and Christian empires participated in these atrocities.

            4.) Again, the number of years a people live in a land, doesn’t give them the right to nullify other people’s rights.

            5.) The majority of Palestinians may “want” no Israeli state (like the majority of Israeli’s don’t desire a Palestinian state), but the majority of Palestinians are willing to accept a deal involving a 2-state solution on legal 1967 borders (like most Israeli’s).

            6.) Name me an Arab country that systematically treats its citizens like Israel treats the Palestinians in the occupied territories.

            7.) The only Jews in Palestine are illegal settlers who are using Palestinian natural resources, and occasionally participate in raids on Palestinian farms/houses. They aren’t treated well, and for good reason.

            • Allahisgreat

              Under international law whether it be the Balfour Declaration or the San Remo Conference or the League of Nations Jews have superior claims under ANY applicable law to both pre- and post-1967 Israel.

              And I’m not even including The Biblical texts Pally. You know the ones – your Muslim Arab buddies kill in the name of the same God/ Allah but deny Allahs word when it comes to who owns the land. Funny that

        • http://wwrtc.blogspot.com Art Deco

          A majority of Palestinians (via polls) want a two-state solution,

          Rubbish. North of a third of the Arab population of the West Bank and Gaza find anything short of the dissolution of the State of Israel unacceptable. That is a critical mass of sufficient dimensions to disrupt any settlement. Another thirty percent have a non-negotiable condition that a fuzzily defined set of Arabs be allowed to settle in Israel at their own discretion. We know what that’s about.

          Everyone with a political object has to play the cards they have, sister.

          • Kane

            Not sure what polls you are looking at, but all the ones I see generally show 40-50% of Palestinians supporting a 2-state solution, with 20-30% supporting a democratic one-state solution. The numbers are somewhat similar for Israeli’s.

            Also, the Right of Return you allude to is a right that is universally recognized as legally belonging to the Palestinians. In the 2001 negotiations, Israel and Palestinian leadership agreed to let anywhere from a few hundreds to a few thousand return, with the rest being settled in the new Palestinian state.

            • http://wwrtc.blogspot.com Art Deco

              “Right of Return” is code for the destruction of Israel by slow boat. You’ve outed yourself.

            • allahisgreat

              @Kane

              1. what of the jews rights of return? near 1million ethnically cleansed factor in thjat Iraq Libya and others state no Jews will be allowed back

              2. what of the jews rights of return to judah and samaria in NuPalestine

              3. which arabs get ROR the 3-400000 who left of their own accord; or the 5 million who have never set foot in Israel no helped build it or contributed anything to it

              4.the few who lived there pre 1948 and are still living, and because they started the (ALL IN FACT) war of Jew annihilation were demanded to leave -as they would in ANY western democracy

              we’re waiting!

      • Gustavo CL

        In theory the Palestinians could accept all Israeli conditions and have their state tomorrow. It would be not much larger than the Vatican.

        • http://wwrtc.blogspot.com Art Deco

          Stop lying.

          • deedee

            “Pro-Palestinian” sanctimonious windbags can’t help but lie. How else can they make their arguments?

    • Allahisgrat

      Gustavo. You are sooooooooo wrong. The nufascist left and the Muslim right wing ALWAYS claim ALL ISRAEL is apartheid

      Dumbasses the lot

      what they ignore of course is the TRUE apartheid in PALESTINE, SYRIA IRAN IRAQ QATAR UAE SAUDI ARABIA JORDAN LEBANON KUWAIT BAHRAIN EGYPT SUDAN SOMALIA NIGER NIGERIA etc etc whether gender sexual racial or sectarian apartheid

      • Kane

        None of those countries you list steal the land of “women/gays/minorities”, kill/torture those who resist, and proceed to expel the resulting refugees from the land. They don’t enclose them within the little land they have left, slowly take the rest of the land by force, and then impose a devastating blockade if the efforts fail.
        .
        Israel isn’t the only violator of human rights. Its not even the worst. But to compare its treatment of the Palestinians to Arab treatment of women is ridiculous.

        • cba

          Neither does Israel do any of those things you list.

          The fact that you apparently think it DOES says a lot about the level of indoctrination you’ve been subjected to.

          • Kane

            1.) It is the opinion of the UN (every country except Israel), the International Court of Justice, Human Rights Organizations, and the Security Council, that Israel is illegally occupying stolen land.

            2.) It is the opinion of many of the above institutions, as well as Israeli scholars like Benny Morris, and former Israeli officials like Shlomo Ben Ami, that Israel has expelled/ethnically cleansed the Palestinians from their lands.

            3.) Its official Israeli policy to beat, imprison, and kill any Palestinian who refuses to allow his home to be bulldozed, to make way for a Jewish only settlement.

            As you can see, my “indoctrination”, is what 99% of the world, including parts of Israel, consider reality.

            • deedee

              Do you enjoy vomiting your fetid lies again and again – all around the internet? I bet you think you’re doing a public service, “educating” the world about the true barbaric nature of the Jew. I hope you never plan on visiting there. Did you know it’s also official Israeli policy to beat, imprison, and kill every tourist that steps foot onto the land? It’s true! 99% of tourists who’ve been there said they never made it out alive!

            • E. Blasberg

              Israel did not “steal” the West Bank. It was attacked in a war and it won that land in the war. This is NOT theft. Before 1967, Jordan occupied the West Bank. Before them, the British. Before them, the Turks. There has NEVER been a “Palestine” (a name given to the land of Israel by the Romans, named after the Philistines who were at that time extinct). Check your facts…

            • Allahisgrat

              1.) It is the opinion of the UN (every country except Israel), the International Court of Justice, Human Rights Organizations, and the Security Council, that Israel is illegally occupying stolen land.

              Drivel. Already answered.

              2.) It is the opinion of many of the above institutions, as well as Israeli scholars like Benny Morris, and former Israeli officials like Shlomo Ben Ami, that Israel has expelled/ethnically cleansed the Palestinians from their lands.

              More drivel. Benny Morris is quite clear and categorical that his words have been twisted and made into vicious Jew hate lies. Jews WERE ethnically cleansed. Arabs mostly left if their own accord or were made refugees. Big deal! Twenty million people were made refugees post WW2 -they were ALL settled in the adopted homeland. Why not these Arabs left to rot in camps by other Arabs funny that eh?

              3.) Its official Israeli policy to beat, imprison, and kill any Palestinian who refuses to allow his home to be bulldozed, to make way for a Jewish only settlement.

              HahahhahahahahahahahahhahahahahahhahahahahahhahahhahahhahahahahahhahahahahahhahahahahhahahahahhahahHahhHhHahhahahhahahhahahahahhahahahah

              PROJECTION PROJECTION PROJECTION. YOUR MASK IS SLIPPING PALLY

              As you can see, my “indoctrination”, is what 99% of the world, including parts of Israel, consider reality.

              Really? How sad for you being so full if hate and lies

        • Allahisgrat

          The wort violators of human rights are all,the countries I’ve listed

          The arabs chose war they lost land rights. How else do you think Jordan Iraq Saudi Arabia ISRAEL Syria Lebanon came into being Pally. Time for some history research eh?

          The Country of palestine has never existed in the history of the world; these pals don’t own any land they never have

          ottomans then British mandate then division then war. No Palestinians. Not even in UN Resolution 242. Which IS still binding by the way. Read it? I have. U lose!

  • Allahisgrat

    @kane

    1.) The UN, International Court, Human Rights Organizations, and the legally binding Security Council, have ALL said settlements in Gaza, the West Bank, and Jerusalem, are illegal.

    Hahahahahah. They said it did they. So that makes their OPINION legitimate. Don’t be ridiculous. I asked you for ANY legally binding LAW that says they are illegal and you give me some Jew hate organs “opinions”. The UN as u damn well know is run by the Arab oil sheiks and their minions The inhuman rights organs are left wing Jew hate nufascists who ignore most of all,that’s going on in the world but never fail to condemn Israel. they don’t make laws Pally. Which international court which has jurisdiction in the matter passed a legally binding verdict on the settlements? Answer ; NONE EVER. So please my palsabarist friend you really must come up with some facts NOT silly Jew hate opinions. IM WAITING

    2.) Who cares when they came, as long as they owned the land? A lot of Muslim Arabs immigrated to Palestine after 1900. The vast majority of Jews in Palestine didn’t arrive until 1915. That doesn’t take away basic rights for either group.

    ah but they NEVER owned the land. And THATS the point. The Jews owned the land. how? They bought it at vastly inflated prices from absentee Arabs and ottomans. These “Palestinians’ left it to fester and decay for decades. The Jews reclaimed it from fetid swamp and arrad dessert.

    The majority came post 1948 actually AFTER THEY WERE ETHNICALLY CLEANSED FROM MUSLIM ARAB COUNTRIES and Iran. Almost a million in total! Most emigrated to Israel who took them in. What did the Arabs do with their refugees. They kept them in camps and denied them basis rights. And have continued to do so for 65 yrs.

    3.) The Palestinians as we know them didn’t rampage, enslave, or kill anybody. If you are talking about history hundreds of years ago, be aware that Jews in both the Islamic and Christian empires participated in these atrocities.

    The Pals didn’t exist until 1964 Pally and by God they’ve killed thousands if innocents. The Arabs meanwhile did kill and rape and enslave.

    Jews? Oh they just tried to defend themselves against these atrocities first from the Christians then the Muslim Arabs. They didn’t participate silly Next.

    4.) Again, the number of years a people live in a land, doesn’t give them the right to nullify other people’s rights.

    Agreed. These Arabs who stayed in Israel post 1948 have full and equal rights as any Jew. -what rights do Jews have in their also ancient homelands of Judea and Samaria. AGAIN. IM WAITING!!!!!!! You do know any house sold to a Jew is punishable by death right? You do know Palestine is Judenrein yes? You do know ALL rights of Jews in Palestine are denied right?

    5.) The majority of Palestinians may “want” no Israeli state (like the majority of Israeli’s don’t desire a Palestinian state), but the majority of Palestinians are willing to accept a deal involving a 2-state solution on legal 1967 borders (like most Israeli’s).

    Sooooooooo wrong my friend on BOTH counts. What ” legal “1967 borders. What rubbish. There are none! You really are making this up now. The PLO who run the West Bank and HAMAS are quite clear. No Israel only Palestine. See their maps of the region my friend. Wheres the Jewish state?

    6.) Name me an Arab country that systematically treats its citizens like Israel treats the Palestinians in the occupied territories.

    NONE- Israel’s treats ITS Arabs citizens far better than ANY Arab state. Arabs have more rights in Israel. More freedoms more democracy than ANY Muslim Arab state INCLUDING PALESTINE

    7.) The only Jews in Palestine are illegal settlers who are using Palestinian natural resources, and occasionally participate in raids on Palestinian farms/houses. They aren’t treated well, and for good reason.

    Hahahaahhahaha again not illegal. Why can’t a Jew build a house anywhere. Say, in Judea and. Samaria. Why can’t a Jew live in Palestine. Millions of Palestinians live in Israel. Are you suggesting these Pals are racist antisemitic fascist nazis? These pals stone to death or attempt to stone,to shoot, to blow up, to rocket and mortar attack Jews EVERY FRIGGIN DAY care to comment?

  • Allahisgrat

    One question Kane

    When Jordan annexed and owned Judea Samaria and E Jerusalem between 1948 and 1967 why no Palestinian state They had 19yrs to get their. Sh*t together. Right?

  • Pingback: Thank you Mr. Harper | Anne's Opinions

  • ted ranony

    The settlements are illegal. It is colonization. No matter how loud you yell, the truth is clear to any thinking person.

  • Allahisgreat

    @ted

    Wrong. Go ask Obama. Better still keep shouting and some will believe U. It’s the Goebbels theory