Another New York Times Jewish Problem

Where’s the beef, NYT? - Photo: Brian of London
Where’s the beef, NYT? – Photo: Brian of London

In case you didn’t know it, there’s a bit of argy-bargy going on in Argentina right now. They were all set to release the findings of a long investigation into the infamous bombing of Jewish community centre in Buenos Aires in 1994, which is widely believed to have been the work of Hezbollah acting on Iranian orders. In fact there are long standing international arrest warrants for various Iranians (some of whom have now become very senior in the Iranian regime).

On the eve of giving testimony, the head of the investigation was found dead with a pistol in his hand, a bullet wound in his head and slumped against the inside of his locked bathroom. The only detail the story lacked was how many shots to the head he’d managed to kill himself with. The initial, official, claims of suicide have now been undermined by the country’s President, Cristina Kirchner, now admitting that Alberto Nisman was, in fact, murdered.

Step in the New York Times: oh yes, there is no limit to how many times in a week Israellycool will criticise this diseased organ. See if you can spot the problem with this paragraph:

Some experts, including a former American F.B.I. agent who helped the Argentines in their investigation, have questioned the claims of direct Iranian involvement in the bombing. Still, Argentina had limited relations with Iran for years, partly because of the investigation’s importance to the nation’s large Jewish population.

Well lots of countries have had “limited relations with Iran for years” and that doesn’t seem to be related to the number of Jews in their countries. And what’s that about “large Jewish population”? Oh fact checkers of the New York Times, how many Jews does it take before you say a country has a “large Jewish population”?

Turning to the Book of Knowledge™, Wikipedia, we find:

Country or Territory Core Jewish Population Proportion of country population Enlarged Jewish Population Proportion of country population
 Israel 6,180,300 75.4% 6,332,900[2] 79.394%
 United States 5,400,000 – 6,800,000 2.11% 8,300,000[2] 2.644%
 Gibraltar 600 1.935%
 Uruguay 34,000[25] 1.134% 50,000
 Canada 380,000 1.089% 500,000 1.433%
 France 478,000 0.751% 600,000 0.943%
 Argentina 230,000[19] 0.575% 300,000

So while yes, Argentina does make the top 7 of countries with Jews as a percentage of total population (and what’s the deal with Gibraltar!!!), I’d hardly say that 230,000 Jews should really be seen as pushing a nation of 41m people around.

So do is there really a problem with Jews having undue influence and stoping the fine Argentinians exporting their beef and grain to Iran in return for cheap oil? Is it just possible that non-Jewish Argentinians were also upset by Iranian proxies blowing up Argentinians (who also happen to be Jews) or is the NYT implying that no Jews can really be completely Argentinian? Where have I heard that kind of canard before?

Oh dear New York Times, whatever did you mean by “large Jewish population”? Did you mean to say “Jewish problem” instead?

9 thoughts on “Another New York Times Jewish Problem”

    1. Unless things have changed, I think Gibraltar may have the most religious (by percentage) Jewish population in the West.

  1. Too many Jews? Well, according to the Jewish reporters in the New York Times (and the other New York papers), there certainly are too many religious Jews in New York City, which is why the papers there have such a strong anti-Orthodox slant. You can contrast that with the Baltimore Sun, where the slant is (or was) reversed (unless they are reporting on Israel); presumably there aren’t enough religious Jews in Baltimore (which BTW has the highest Orthodox percentage of any major US city) to be a threat.

    Do you know that the New York Times, when reporting on the quest to get the UN to create a Jewish State, referred to Mizrachi (the Religious Zionist party, currently Jewish Home, more or less) as “ultra-Orthodox”? True story.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top